I 'm really sorry you have had so many problems.
Back in the day, battery, alternator and even old-style generators were easy to diagnose. These days with certain electronics drawing power even when the car is not even running...well that's beyond my knowledge.
I do know alternators rarely fail. If it's not charging properly, it could be a loose belt, a loose connection, or some kind of computer fault.
Also, and as you said, the average life span of a battery is roughly 5 years.
I have a cheap battery/alternator tester. Sometimes it says battery good, other times it says battery good but needs charging.
Since the battery is approaching five years, I suspect its more that than a bad alternator.
Fortunately, in my hometown we have an excellent battery shop. They will test your whole system with far more sophisticated equipment than what you might buy on Amazon for free.
If you have similar battery shop....go there and see what they say. To be clear, I'm not talking about AutoZone or similar national brands. They may be fine, but I don't trust them.
It's a shame that what was once simple things to diagnose are now so complicated that you don't know what to believe.
Sorry for the last part...I'll get off my soapbox now...lol
Back in the day, battery, alternator and even old-style generators were easy to diagnose. These days with certain electronics drawing power even when the car is not even running...well that's beyond my knowledge.
I do know alternators rarely fail. If it's not charging properly, it could be a loose belt, a loose connection, or some kind of computer fault.
Also, and as you said, the average life span of a battery is roughly 5 years.
I have a cheap battery/alternator tester. Sometimes it says battery good, other times it says battery good but needs charging.
Since the battery is approaching five years, I suspect its more that than a bad alternator.
Fortunately, in my hometown we have an excellent battery shop. They will test your whole system with far more sophisticated equipment than what you might buy on Amazon for free.
If you have similar battery shop....go there and see what they say. To be clear, I'm not talking about AutoZone or similar national brands. They may be fine, but I don't trust them.
It's a shame that what was once simple things to diagnose are now so complicated that you don't know what to believe.
Sorry for the last part...I'll get off my soapbox now...lol